Absorption Costing vs Marginal Costing: Differences and Examples
Why the same business can report two different profits, and how to reconcile them.
Home › Cost Accounting › Absorption vs Marginal Costing
The two methods side by side
| Absorption costing | Marginal costing | |
|---|---|---|
| Unit cost includes | Direct materials, direct labour, variable overhead and fixed production overhead | Direct materials, direct labour and variable overhead only |
| Fixed production overhead | Absorbed into units; part is held in inventory | Charged in full to the period |
| Inventory valued at | Full production cost | Variable production cost |
| Income statement shows | Gross profit | Contribution, then profit |
| Main use | External financial reporting | Internal decisions |
The example
A company sells a product at 30. The variable production cost is 14 per unit. Fixed production overhead is 50,000 a period, absorbed at 5 per unit on a normal output of 10,000 units, so the absorption cost per unit is 14 + 5 = 19. Assume there are no other costs and the company produces 10,000 units in each period.
Period 1: produce 10,000, sell 8,000
| Absorption costing | Marginal costing | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales (8,000 × 30) | 240,000 | Sales | 240,000 |
| Cost of sales (8,000 × 19) | (152,000) | Variable cost (8,000 × 14) | (112,000) |
| Contribution | 128,000 | ||
| Fixed overhead | (50,000) | ||
| Profit | 88,000 | Profit | 78,000 |
Difference: 88,000 − 78,000 = 10,000. Closing inventory rose by 2,000 units (10,000 made, 8,000 sold). Absorption costing carries 2,000 × 5 = 10,000 of fixed overhead forward in inventory, so less is charged this period and profit is higher.
Period 2: produce 10,000, sell 12,000
Sales exceed production, so the 2,000 units in opening inventory are sold as well.
| Absorption costing | Marginal costing | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales (12,000 × 30) | 360,000 | Sales | 360,000 |
| Cost of sales (12,000 × 19) | (228,000) | Variable cost (12,000 × 14) | (168,000) |
| Contribution | 192,000 | ||
| Fixed overhead | (50,000) | ||
| Profit | 132,000 | Profit | 142,000 |
Difference: 142,000 − 132,000 = 10,000, now in the other direction. Inventory fell by 2,000 units. The 10,000 of fixed overhead that was held in inventory from Period 1 is released and charged to cost of sales under absorption costing.
The rule to remember
| Situation | Which profit is higher? |
|---|---|
| Production > sales (inventory rises) | Absorption costing |
| Production < sales (inventory falls) | Marginal costing |
| Production = sales | Same profit |
Over the two periods the total profit is identical: 88,000 + 132,000 = 220,000 under absorption, and 78,000 + 142,000 = 220,000 under marginal costing. The methods differ only in when fixed overhead reaches the income statement.
Which method should you use?
- Absorption costing for external reporting. Accounting standards such as IAS 2 require inventory to include a share of production overheads.
- Marginal costing for internal decisions. It highlights contribution, which is what matters for pricing, special orders, break-even and make-or-buy decisions. It also stops profit from being affected by building up inventory.
Common mistakes
- Expecting identical profits. They are the same only when production equals sales.
- Getting the direction wrong. Rising inventory means absorption costing shows the higher profit.
- Using absorption cost per unit for short-term decisions. The absorbed fixed overhead does not change with the decision.
Quick check
1. A firm produces 5,000 units and sells 4,000. Fixed overhead is 6 per unit. By how much do the profits differ, and which is higher?
Inventory rose by 1,000 units, so the difference is 1,000 × 6 = 6,000. Absorption costing shows the higher profit.
2. Which method values closing inventory in published financial statements?
Absorption costing, because standards require production overheads to be included in inventory cost.
Practise with Problem 6.
Frequently asked questions
Why do absorption and marginal costing give different profits?
Absorption costing defers part of the fixed production overhead in closing inventory, while marginal costing charges all of it to the period. The profit difference equals the change in inventory units multiplied by the fixed overhead per unit.
Is marginal costing allowed for financial statements?
Not for valuing inventory in published accounts under IFRS. It is used for internal management reporting and decisions.
Do the two methods ever give the same profit?
Yes, when opening and closing inventory are equal, which happens when production equals sales.
Keep learning
This lesson is for general learning. Terminology and layouts vary by syllabus and country.